Robert Sherwood: Since I've never heard of this Neutral Milk Hotel band, I have to go with Belle & Sebastian, which is another band I have gone out of my way to avoid.
Dean Cartwright: Belle and Sebastian all lovely spring day at the beach easing your feet in the sea long!
Mitchell W Feldstein: funny when there are the ones where i have never heard any of either bands music.
Tex Ramone: If you don't like In The Aeroplane Over The Sea you are dead inside. NMH all day long
Jack Livingston: easy one NMH. For keeping experimental pop alive when it was gasping. One of the only bands I will still go see live. (and they are coming to Bmore soon!)
Nolen Strals: Belle & Sebastian. Better lyricism, less JESUS in their Jesus music
Howard Yang: because they actually have a sense of humor in their lyrics (breaking the America voting block)- Belle & Sebastian
Michelle Dwyer: Belle & Sebastian even though they are a little too fru fru sometimes
Colleen Pelser: you mean which one makes me puke more?